Should the Church Defy the Government?


Authority conspiracies COVID-19 faith Gospel Government. the Church

Should the Church Defy the Government?

12 August 2020 Hits:2826

A few weeks ago, I received an email from a guy who calls himself an Evangelist. He wanted to challenge me about Bayside Church, and other churches, closing down services during the Global Pandemic. He wrote:

What about God’s word “do not forsake the gathering together of the saints and do so more as the day draws nearer”!! We have already obeyed man over God and now discovered it’s all a lie to take. [sic.] Freedom from the people and increase fear and the control of the government to usher in one world order. Please challenge people to fight injustice and choose God Over man including church. Pastors should not have closed their church’s. So many people look to you ??? Don’t be a coward brother !! Set example Expose injustice and ungodly anti christ agenda

I get quite a few kooky messages, most of which I ignore, but I thought I’d address this one as it contains so many fallacies that are being spread around at present. Fortunately, in Australia “there appears to be little or no appetite to go against the various Public Health Orders in each state. Our largest churches such as Hillsong are meeting online, and church leaders have committed their networks to understand and follow the rules, seeking advice from Health Authorities where something is unclear.” (Quoted from Eternity Newspaper).   I believe the Australian church has got it right.

Meanwhile, in the USA

In the USA, there’s been a slightly different approach. Even though most churches have abided by government guidelines, a small, vocal group of pastors has “begun to bristle at government-imposed restrictions on their worship.” (Quoted from The Atlantic). 

Some have reopened; others have sued for their right to gather, claiming the restrictions are unconstitutional and a threat to religious freedom. A few others refused to shut down at all.

History Repeats

Sadly, much of this is history repeating itself. During the 1918-19 Spanish Flu Pandemic, many of the same measures were put into place that we’ve seen during COVID-19. Face masks, social distancing, personal hygiene, and closing of places of public gathering. While most people complied, some saw this as some sort of insidious agenda of State control and bucked the system. It was the second wave of the Spanish Flu that killed the most people. One thing we learn from history is that we rarely learn from history!

Churches that sue for their rights and their religious freedom do nothing to advance the good news of Jesus. The Gospel calls Jesus’ followers to “not [look] to your own interests, but each of you to the interests of the others” (Phil 2:4).

The Spanish Flu wasn’t a threat to religious freedom, it was a threat to public health. COVID-19 is the same. After 1919, churches and other public gathering places were reopened once again, and the world moved into The Roaring Twenties. Closures, wearing masks, and social distancing were temporary measures aimed at bringing communities through a health crisis with as few casualties as possible. Same today!

Some churches bristle because they are not deemed “an essential service” like liquor stores! As a Christian and a pastor, I think the church is essential, but I know I stand with the minority. The closure of church gatherings is not about being essential. It’s about restricting the congregating of people and the spreading of a very contagious virus. Whatever you think of liquor stores, people don’t congregate there.

Church at Walmart

In the US, a church group recently decided to resist the trend and have a service at a Walmart pharmacy to protest that pharmacies were open but churches were closed:

The singing of my African American brothers and sisters is stunning, and I hope no one was infected with COVID-19. Only time will tell. It should be remembered, though, that when people sing (or talk loudly like preaching), they spray out a shower of secretions. According to fluid physics expert Professor Con Doolan, these aerosol particles remain suspended in the air, potentially spreading coronavirus. If you’re standing too close to an infected person when they cough or sing, you could breathe in the particles they have projected into the air (see article). 

And so, while I see so many people cheering on this church, if their actions cause sickness and death are they really singing God’s praises? Would God be pleased or saddened by the behaviour of his children?

Other churches who defied the US Government faced significant backlash from neighbours. One woman stood outside a church and held up a sign that read, “you killed my grandma.” Is this the testimony of the Gospel the church wants to communicate to a world that God loves and for whom Jesus died?

Listening to God not Man

The most well-known church to defy the government is John MacArthur’s Grace Community Church in California. 

Their statement is convincing on the first read with lots of scripture verses to enforce their argument.

Itt’s important to remember that the church is not being restricted by Government unnecessarily. For example, no one is telling churches and Christians not to preach the Gospel as the authorities did to Peter and John: “So they called the apostles back in and commanded them never again to speak or teach in the name of Jesus.”

If the Government ever banned us from speaking and teaching about Jesus, I would respond in the same way the apostles did: “Judge for yourselves whether it is right in God’s sight to listen to you rather than God.”

This not the case today even though Grace Community Church says it is. All churches can preach about Jesus and teach God’s Word. There are no restrictions placed on us in this regard.

So, that’s what we’re doing at Bayside Church, and we’re seeing people come to Jesus and grow in their faith. We’re helping the underprivileged with groceries and cooked food. Church members are keeping in touch with one another and serving one another. The church is alive, healthy, and vibrant.

It’s my opinion that the “evangelist” who wrote to me recently is missing the point. It appears he’s bought into fear and conspiracies about a one-world government and an antichrist agenda. While these beliefs are widely held by many Christians today, they are based more on the Left Behind novels than on God’s Word. I’ll explore that in next week’s blog!

The Near Future

Once this current crisis is over, restrictions will be eased, and small gatherings will once again be safe. Before the resurgence of COVID-19 in Melbourne, Bayside Church was about to restart gatherings of up to 50 people. Many of our Connect Groups were already meeting in-person, and we were looking at doing some meetings outdoors with more significant numbers. If the current restrictions work, we should get back to that in a few weeks.

While church buildings are an incredible asset, we need to remember that the church is people, not buildings. I appreciate the excellent facility that Bayside Church works from and gathers in, but it’s important to remember that the church did very well for the first three centuries with no building at all.

During this pandemic, Christians are blessed with technology that helps us stay in touch with one another. While this ultimately is no substitute for in-person meetings, it’s better than nothing.

During the Spanish Flu pandemic, some pastors wrote letters and Bible studies for their congregations and posted them in letterboxes. Today we meet on Facebook, YouTube, and Zoom. I’ve had Bayside Church people tell me they have never felt so connected with Christie and me and with their church.

The building may be closed, but the church is open!

Rob Buckingham

Senior Minister

Share Us

11 replies on “Should the Church Defy the Government?”

Zizi paltossays:

A wonderful and sensible blog.
As always Pastor Rob, writes intellectually and with love.
Thank you

Terrence Baxtersays:

Great BLOG Rob
Well balanced perspective

Matt Murphysays:

Very well said Rob. Surely if we have God’s heart we want to care for one another by restricting COVID-19 spread. We shall meet together again at the right time and I look forward to it. In the meantime I enjoy meeting and fellowshipping online with you and other Baysiders. Stay well and God Bless you Ps Rob.

Michael Gilmuorsays:

A very sensible approach to the current lockdown. The church is the people and the government is not saying we cannot meet but they are saying we cannot meet in person. In this modern age this leaves a myriad of options available from zoom, skype, telephone, messenger etc. As one person said to me, this is the most comfortable lockdown in history……

Linda Opolionsays:

Totally agree. Christians creating fear of the New world order and getting consumed by conspiracy theories is just as bad as the pandemic itself. It makes Christians look bad and they are focussing on the enemies work and not the work of God which is so much more powerful. Jesus defeated the enemy and we as Christians are seated with him. Spread Love not fear. The Kingdom of Heaven is near.

Paul Topysays:

Thank you for providing a balanced and Godly view point.

Ann Johnstonesays:

Well said Rob. Just like the early church, today we are experiencing differences/limitations in location, but the end result is the same – the advancement of God’s Kingdom on earth. After all, ultimately nothing can prevent God’s Kingdom from advancing, as it is primarily His concern – not ours.

Julie Szabosays:

Thanks for writing, Rob.

Richard Warnersays:

Amen Rob. In the midst of confusion and some madness we need you sanity!


Oh! You are so sensible. I have a few friends who are hard core with this being the final days and the One World Order and it is nice to hear your clear voice in my head.
In some cases, it does not matter what you say to those people, they are simply not listening and do not want to listen to the alternative.
Thanks for posting this one.

Marlene Smithsays:

I appreciate all you have said, but I would not be sarcastic either about the “evangelist” who wants to make a stand for what he sees as God’s way of doing things. Scriptures can be taken out of context to suit one’s personal views, as you know. I am too old to cope with Zoom, and nothing takes the place of worshipping our Lord together, in person. I also bear in mind that many Christians have been and are being persecuted for standing strong. The signs of the times are there, no matter how positive you want to be. There is urgency to spread the Word and “evangelise”. I don’t believe in suing anyone or going to court over attacks on us, Christians. We must not be cowards, stand on God’s Word, love our enemies, and endure whatever is to come. “Will I find faith when I return?’ Jesus asks sadly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Our team would love to help! Please feel free to contact us if you need further information about any of our services, groups or facilities.

Contact Us